I have a lot of difficulty compartmentalizing things into years, but I thought I’d give it a try with my comics, since I only keep a single year’s worth in my apartment before moving them to a friend’s for storage. Because of this new set-up, I was able to take a look at the comics I got in 2005 and see what I liked and what I didn’t like. Here is a list of some of my high points, low points and other observations about some titles.
- Best Series ? Ex Machina (Brian K. Vaughan; Tony Harris)
- Best Superhero Comic ? Birds of Prey (Gail Simone; Various Artists)
- Best Writing on a Regular Series ? Wonder Woman (Greg Rucka)
- Most Consistently Excellent ? Y: The Last Man (Brian K. Vaughan; Goran Sud?uka)
- Carrying on the Neil Gaiman Legacy – Lucifer (Mike Carey; Peter Gross)
- Best Event ? Infinite Crisis and Various Spin-Offs (Geoff Johns; Phil Jimenez)
- Biggest Surprise (Positive) ? Young Avengers (Allan Heinberg; Jim Cheung)
- Most Refreshing Writer ? Dan Slott (She-Hulk; Thing; Great Lakes Avengers)
- Best Miniseries Starring an Obscure Character ? TIE! Drax the Destroyer (Keith Giffen; Mitch Breitweiser) & Stormbreaker: The Saga of Beta Ray Bill (Michael Avon Oeming & Dan Berman; Andrea Divito)
- Best Epilogue ? Phoenix: Endsong (Greg Pak; Greg Land)
- Best Use of a Prestige Artist ? TIE! Justice (Doug Braithwaite & Alex Ross) & Phoenix: Endsong (Greg Land)
- Best X-Men ? X-Men (Peter Milligan; Salvador Larroca)
- Best of the Four ? 4 (Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa; Various Artists)
- Best Ultimate Title ? The Ultimates 2 (Mark Millar; Bryan Hitch)
- Most Ambitious Mess ? Seven Soldiers of Victory (Grant Morrison; Various Artists)
- Most Welcome Use of a Character ? Zatanna
- Nicest Cameo by an Obscure Character ? Black Orchid in Day of Vengeance
- It?s About Time ? The Reunion of Katchoo and Francine in Strangers in Paradise (Terry Moore)
- Biggest Disappointment ? Kitty Pryde: Shadow & Flame (Akira Yoshida; Paul Smith)
- Stuck in a Rut, or Why Am I Still Buying This Crap? ? Uncanny X-Men (Chris Claremont; Various Aritsts)
- Most Overrated ? Astonishing X-Men (Joss Whedon; John Cassaday) ? Plus, there were only 6 issues
- Most Dismal Event ? House of M (Brian Michael Bendis; Olivier Coipel)
- Shadow of Its Former Self ? The New Avengers (Brian Michael Bendis; Various Artists)
- Most Pointless High Profile Resurrection ? Hal Jordan/Green Lantern
- Most Welcome but Shoddily Executed Resurrection ? Donna Troy
- Great Style, Too Much Substance ? Otherworld (Phil Jimenez)
A couple of things I want to mention further. This is only the second time in my history of reading comics that I have stopped buying The Avengers. The first was when Rob Leifield was writing it (it picked it up a few issues later when Walt Simonson took over). What Brian Michael Bendis has done with a former favorite title of mine is inexcusable. It in no way resembles a comic called The Avengers, and despite the use of one of my favorite characters from the 1970’s (Spider-Woman) it just plain sucks. DC knocks one out of the park with its massive Infinite Crisis event, including four terrific lead-in mini-series, and other regular titles picking up some compelling threads (the Wonder Woman/Superman clash specifically.) I am the first to admit how much I enjoy Young Avengers, a title I was sure to hate. Allan Heinberg has made a convert out of me. It’s great to read Dan Slott’s work, bringing old-style superheroics back to comics with a nice dose of humor on titles such as She-Hulk, The Thing and the Great Lakes Avengers mini-series. Who would have thought I would have enjoyed miniseries starring such obscure characters as Drax the Destroyer and Beta Ray Bill so much? And the attention paid to Zatanna this year has been very much welcomed. Kitty Pryde, on the other hand, a much-loved character, disappointed in her mini-series, which I just felt fell flat. The X-Men titles themselves were a mixed bag. I bucked the majority and really enjoyed Peter Milligan’s work on X-Men, while being greatly disappointed in Joss Whedon’s Astonishing X-Men despite a strong start in 2004. And Chris Claremont? Just give it up. Greg Pak did an astounding job adding another chapter to the Jean Grey/Phoenix saga. And to think, I’ve had dinner with him! And as for my 
boyfriend, talented artist/writer Phil Jimenez? He had a mixed year; his astounding pencils make Infinite Crisis so beautiful, and add some wonder to Otherworld, but his muddled writing in that series and the non-event, The Return of Donna Troy were disappointing. Finally there’s House of M. The less said about that mockery the better.
Then there were some titles that were solidly enjoyed, but didn’ tmake any of the “best categories.” Geoff Johns continues his superlative work on JSA, while DC’s struggling title Manhunter continues to keep my interest. J. Michael Straczynski’s Supreme Power remains one of the most refreshing superhero comics, but it will have strong competition with the revamped return of Peter David’s excellent X-Factor, the most anticipated series of 2006. Pulse remains the best series by a writer I don’t like (Brian Michael Bendis) and the Legion of Superheroes, while interesting and fun to read, isn’t catching on the way Mark Waid probably intended. All-in-all, I can say it was a year filled with ups and downs. Now I just have to save some money and start dropping some of the titles that continuously disappointed me throughout the year.