Fleetwood Mac Tracks, #15 – 11

Fleetwood Mac ca. 1975

As we close in on the Top 10, it’s the last time we’ll see all three of our songwriters appear. One of them is going to be locked out of the Top 10. We’ll also see a surprise appearance of a track from Mystery to Me. And things are certainly going to start getting Christine McVie heavy, as in this case, with three of these five songs coming from her.

#15 – Over My Head (McVie, C.) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

To the band’s surprise, Warner Bros. selected “Over My Head” as the lead single of the newly transformed Fleetwood Mac’a 1975 album, Fleetwood Mac. It was the song the band thought was least likely to be released as a single. The strategy worked, as “Over My Head” became the first single to hit the Billboard Top 100 since “Oh Well” in 1969, which climbed to #55. “Over My Head” was also the band’s first Top 20 single ever, reaching that pinnacle in early 1976.

The song is penned by Christine McVie, and is classic 70’s era McVie through and through. She composed it on a small, portable electric piano, in a tiny apartment in Malibu, CA where she lived with her then-husband, John McVie. While it’s a fairly straightforward, soft-rock, pop song, what makes it so special is the amazing texture in the recording. As a kid, I used to love the novelty of the song already in progress and fading in. Christine’s Vox Continental organ and Lindsey’s low-key, chugging rhythm guitar provide the major drive for the song, with Christine’s electric piano punching accent chords. John McVie’s rolling bass sets the easy rhythm of the tune. Lindsey’s harmonic flourishes and Fleetwood’s unique bongos are the finishing touches to build a rich, palette.

“Over My Head” also features one of my favorite, and to infrequent Mac moments: when Christine and Stevie sing together. Their harmony on the bridge is especially fun in the live version of the song (which I’ve also included – minor point of interest, the live performance features one of the only times I’ve noticed Buckingham using a pick to play guitar). Of Christine’s vocal performance, Billboard magazine said, “a completely distinctive voice, with a sexy huskiness that is unique in pop today.” So true. Lyrically there’s nothing terribly surprising going on here. Christine is lamenting the fact that she’s involved with a man who runs hot and cold, and she can’t decide if it’s worth it to stick around. She is in over her head.

“Over My Head”
Fleetwood Mac performing “Over My Head” on Midnight Special

#14 – Don’t Stop (McVie, C.) Rumours (1977)

Possibly one Mac’s most enduring songs, and a great moment of optimism on the otherwise fractious Rumours album, “Don’t Stop” is another Christine McVie-penned tune, and following in the footsteps of Fleetwood Mac’s “World Turning,” is the second in what would become a series, of McVie/Buckingham duets. McVie revealed that Buckingham helped her craft the lyrics in the verses because their personal sensibilities overlapped. Some say the song is Christine’s message to John after their divorce, although usually Christine just talks about it being generally just an song about optimism.

To create the sound for “Don’t Stop,” McVie played the piano part on both a conventional, acoustic piano, and also a specially treated “tack piano,” where nails are placed on the points where the hammers hit the strings, producing a more percussive sound. It’s often used in the honky tonk style of piano playing, and it’s surprisingly effective, giving “Don’t Stop” a decidedly honky-tonk feel. Christine has fun with the piano part throwing in some flashier bits that she rarely does. It also features a nice, melodic lead guitar solo from Buckingham. Lindsey and Christine alternate verses, and share vocal duties on the chorus. Stevie provides back-up vocals during the closing bars. In the live version, all three vocalists sing the choruses in unison. Otherwise, it’s a highly enjoyable, upbeat pop track, with a catch hook.

“Don’t Stop” was the third single from Rumours, following “Go Your Own Way” and “Dreams.” It climbed all the way to #3. The song had a second life when Bill Clinton used it as his Presidential campaign theme song in 1992. Upon winning the election, Clinton persuaded the Rumours lineup of the group to perform the song for his inaugural ball in 1993, the first time they had played live together since 1982.

“Don’t Stop”
Yes, Mick was clearly on something during this performance.

#13 – Crystal (Nicks) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

Here’s a case of a song ending up much higher on my list than I would have predicted before I started listening to all these songs again to see how I would react. “Crystal” is an interesting anomaly for Fleetwood Mac, as it was written by Nicks, but sung by Buckingham. It was also a previously recorded and released for the Buckingham Nicks album but rerecorded by Fleetwood Mac for this album. American record producer Keith Olsen produced both the Buckingham Nicks and Fleetwood Mac albums, and he insisted both times that Lindsey sing the lead vocal. Stevie would not get to sing the lead part on the song she wrote until she recorded a third version for the original soundtrack to the film Practical Magic in 1998.

I always think of “Crystal” paired with “Landslide,” a more famous Stevie Nicks track. Both use imagery that suggests water, reflections, and light, and deal with deep but ephemeral concepts as time and love. “Crystal” seems to be about how a person experiences love through their lifetime. The lyrics are simple and beautiful, and the line that always resonates with me is, “And I have change, oh but you, you remain ageless.” Such a beautiful line and sentiment. I love the Fleetwood Mac version of this song the best, and Lindsey sings it with such tenderness; perhaps the warmest vocal recorded vocal performance of his career. It’s interesting to note that the Fleetwood Mac version of the song is recorded in a different key than the original, with Lindsey singing even higher in his range. It’s so interesting to hear Stevie’s dreamy lyrics sung by someone else. It really works on this one. Then when Stevie comes in with the harmony vocals, it just soars. They two of them always harmonized gorgeously.

I love the way McVie’s bell-like electric piano weaves into the song around Lindsey’s gentle acoustic guitar work in the first verse. Christine also does a great job with the mellotron, an electro-mechanical musical instrument developed England, in 1963, to really fill out the song, and provide the haunting post-chorus licks, and fading solos at the close of the song. The mellotron has such a lovely, mournful sound and I love the way Christine’s closing solo parts sound like it’s just drifting through mountains on the wind. It’s really a very keyboard heavy song, with the piano and mellotron providing all the layers, and the acoustic guitar adding texture. It’s just exquisite.

“Crystal”

#12 – Second Hand News (Buckingham) Rumours (1977)

I feel bad for Lindsey. He really gave so much to Fleetwood Mac, and in some ways was instrumental to their massive success… or at least to their stretching, musically with Tusk and beyond. And yet he doesn’t manage to break into my Top 10, with “Second Hand News” making the highest mark here at #12. His songs are superb, I just like the ones above his better.

“Second Hand News” was always intended to kick-off Rumours. It’s high energy, galloping energy, combined with it’s euphoric kiss-off both jump-started and encapsulated was the album encompassed: the painful dissolution of several relationships that led to an international smash hit. According to Fleetwood Mac biographer Donald Brackett , Buckingham is finding redemption with other women after his failed relationship with Nicks. He sings that although he does not trust his lover and cannot live with her, he cannot live without her as well. “Been down so long, I’ve been tossed around enough. Aw couldn’t you just let me go down and do my stuff?” He just wants to feel good with some lady companions after the ordeal he went through with Nicks.

Buckingham brought an instrumental version of the song to the band early in the process entitled, “Strummer.” (Purportedly he withheld the lyrics to the song as long as possible because he knew Stevie wouldn’t like them.) Buckingham utilized Scottish and Irish folk song influences, and originally the song was to have been set to a march rhythm. Then Buckingham heard the Bee Gees “Jive Talkin'” he wanted to find a more disco groove. In addition, Lindsey added a drum track by pounding on the back of a Naugahyde chair that happened to be in the studio. John McVie originally recorded a flowing, melodic bass part, but while he was on vacation, Buckingham replaced it with a very simple, quarter note bassline. It ultimately worked for the song, and it would herald Buckingham’s eventual totalitarianism in the studio during the Tusk sessions. McVie did rerecord the bass part to Buckingham’s specifications, but added a few flourishes of his own.

I love the galloping rhythm of the opening, and the break-neck speed in which it progresses, aided by Fleetwood’s rolling snare drum. Lindsey’s trademark acoustic flourishes add the texture, and the harmonies supplied by Nicks bring it all together. Christine doesn’t play on the song, but she adds layered, wordless, background vocals that serve the same purpose as her keyboards. In some early concerts, as seen below, Christine McVie played the drum to add additional percussive power as there were no keyboards in the song. In later concerts she added an organ part, that actually seems a little out of place in the song. It’s really a great song and worthy of opening this classic album.

“Second Hand News”
“Second Hand News” Live


#11 – Just Crazy Love (McVie, C.) Mystery to Me (1973)

Talk about a surprise! I had no idea this song from 1973’s Mystery to Me would almost end up cracking the Top 10! I just love this euphoric, joyful, fun song by Christine McVie. She really doesn’t just let go like this very often, and I love listening to it.

Musically, Christine pounds out some piano, while guitarists Bob Welch and Bob Weston supply some bluesy licks on the verses, and big power chords in the chorus. Then-husband Jon McVie takes a stroll through the melody with his base, all anchored by Fleetwood’s steady, but innovative drumming. And above it all, Christine sings beautifully, clearly having fun with the melody that jumps up an octave and back with lost in between while she just relishes this new relationship she’s in.

There’s not much to the song lyrically. She’s just giddy about a new man, and hopes that it turns serious. Even if her friends tells her she’s being foolish, it just feels right to her, and she’s so happy about it. Apparently Christine performed this song at some of her solo gigs in the early 80’s, and I saw her on that tour, but she didn’t play it in Boston. Can’t find a live video of it anywhere, unfortunately, but here is the audio track!

“Just Crazy Love”

Fleetwood Mac Tracks, #20 – 16

Behind the Mask era

It’s all about Lindsey and Christine in this batch, as we really start to explore the cream of the crop. The Top 20 is just packed with amazing songs, and it was really difficult to get them in an order I was satisfied with. Many of the songs from here on out are from the Fleetwood Mac and Rumours days, but a surprising outlier from Behind the Mask pops up in this bottom half of the Top 20. The only track from that album to crack the Top 50!

#20 – Never Going Back Again (Buckingham) Rumours 1977

There are only three Lindsey Buckingham-penned songs in the Top 20, and two of them kick things off. All three are stellar and find him at the top of his craft. All three are from Rumours. “Never Going Back Again” is mainly a song that highlights Lindsey’s proficiency with the guitar, in this case, a finger-picking delight on the acoustic guitar. The melody is so lovely, it is reminiscent of the gorgeous acoustic guitar instrumental lifted form the Buckingham Nicks album called “Stephanie.” I suspect that “Never Going Back Again” was created to be an instrumental track, then Lindsey added vocals to it at the last minute.

It was, in fact, one of the last songs to be written and recorded for the album, and the lyrics reflect a moment in Lindsey’s life where he had ended his relationship with Stevie Nicks, and had started a rebound relationship, and he naively sings he’s not going to repeat the same mistakes again. The lyrics and simple, and reflect an innocence of youth, something Buckingham himself has admitted. During recording, producer Ken Caillat asked the guitar techs to restring Lindsey’s guitar every 20 minute to keep the sound bright and clear. It certainly is that, and the simplicity of the song (just a guitar and vocals) allows both to shine. Lindsey sings with passion and vulnerability.

An earlier demo of the song, then called “Brushes”, because it featured Mick’s snare drum and brushes, also featured Lindsey on electric guitar, playing bell-sounding harmonics to augment the acoustic guitar. (I’ve included the “Brushes” audio track below as well.) It gave the song a music box quality, and while lovely, I’m glad they left it simple with the just the acoustic. “Never Going Back Again” was a staple for several of Fleetwood Mac’s and served as a bit of an emotional catharsis featuring Lindsey wailing his lyrics over the lyrical finger-picking. The song is a favorite from the album among some critics.

#19 – Go Your Own Way (Buckingham) Rumours (1977)

Coming in at #19, another Buckingham track from Rumours, and arguably his most well-known song. I think “Go Your Own Way” deserves to be higher on my list, but there are just too damn many great songs by this band! Every song in the Top 20 is superlative. The first single released from Rumours, it became the bands first Top 10 single.

As has been well-chronicled, all the members in Fleetwood Mac were in crumbling relationships during the writing and recording of Rumours, and two of those couples were in the band.”Go Your Own Way” was the first song written for the album, and is probably the best example, and perhaps the most scathing of the break-up songs. It’s clearly Buckingham working through his pain and anger over break-up with Nicks. Lindsey had known Stevie since he was 16-years-old, and he “was completely devastated when she took off.” Despite this, the two had to work together closely in the band. From Nicks’ perspective, she of Buckingham that he remove the lyrics, “Packing up, shacking up is all you wanna do.” She told Rolling Stone, “Every time those words would come onstage, I wanted to go over and kill him. He knew it, so he really pushed my buttons through that. It was like, ‘I’ll make you suffer for leaving me.’ And I did.”

Musically it’s such an intriguing song. It’s one of Fleetwood Mac’s most rocking songs, but the opening verse is very disorienting. It starts with Buckingham’s straight-forward rhythm guitar, but then the overdubbed acoustic guitar and the intriguing drum drum beats that really pull the song together, do so in such a way that it’s hard to tell where the beat is. Then, with the addition of the organ, some maracas, and the classic three-part harmonies, the chorus just erupts with pained anger. The drumming is really top notch, and Fleetwood comments on how difficult it was for him to get the beat that Lindsey wanted. And the acoustic guitar, which was the last part added, brings the whole song together.

“Go Your Own Way” has been part of every tour the band has played, even if Lindsey wasn’t with them. It’s frequently the set closer, and features an extended lead guitar solo toward the end of the song. Frequently during the performance, Stevie and Lindsey ham it up, facing each other while they sing those painful lines. Buckingham has admitted none of that is genuine. It’s play-acting for the audience, but something tells me there’s some of the hurt deep down still. I’ve included the studio version of the song below, as well as the live version from the Mirage tour in 1982.

Stevie and Christine fooling around during “Go Your Own Way.”

Interesting note: there is one more Buckingham-penned song that I ranked higher than “Go Your Own Way.” Can you figure out which song that might be? Also, interestingly enough, there is one more song with lead vocals by Buckingham that he did not write higher up on my list. Any guesses?

#18 – Skies the Limit (McVie, C; Quintela, E.) Behind the Mask (1990)

I don’t understand why this Christine McVie gem was not a bigger hit. Perhaps it was the lackluster performance of the album from which it came, 1990’s Behind the Mask, the first album since 1975’s Fleetwood Mac without Lindsey Buckingham, who departed after the release of the previous album, Tango in the Night. In addition to the two McVie’s, Nicks, and Fleetwood, guitarists/vocalists Billy Burnette and Rick Vito were added to the line-up. This jaunty of pop confection would have been my choice for the lead single off the album, but instead they released the much blander, “Save Me” (also written by McVie and then husband, Eddie Quintela). That song cracked the US Top 40 at least. At least “Skies the Limit” hit #10 on Billboard’s Adult Contemporary chart. It also kicks off the album.

The lyrics are classic, optimist McVie, describing the first brushes of new love. It’s got a very positive, feel-good message, and the harmonizing between McVie and Nicks is just lovely. I’m not sure why I love this song so much, but there’s something so bright and uplifting about it, it captures me every time I listen to it. And I love the accompanying video, and I only just saw it for the first time about a month ago!

#17 – You Make Loving Fun (McVie, C.) Rumours (1977)

I find it interesting that while relationships were collapsing throughout the band while making Rumours, Lindsey and Stevie were venting their anger and frustration, while Christine was trying to focus on the positive. “You Make Loving Fun” was written about the band’s lighting director, Curry Grant, with whom Christine was having an affair. She initially told her newly ex-husband John that the song was about her dog. “You Make Loving Fun” was the fourth single from Rumours, and was also the bands fourth Top 10 song. I love the funky vibe overlaying the more traditional McVie sound that really makes the song pop. McVie was quoted as saying early tracks of the song were recorded without Buckingham, allowing her to “build the song on my own”.

The verses are driven by McVie’s electric piano and the fabulous springy sounds she played on the clavinet. The fantastic chorus feature McVie’s beautifully controlled vocals, backed by the lush harmonies of the three, and an intricate drum pattern. Fleetwood uses a variety of percussion throughout really adding texture to the song. Lindsey provides great color with guitar filler and a great melodic solo after the first chorus. The song features one of the great outros with a call and response between McVie and her fellow singers. The live version that I’ve included is a very early version from 1977, featuring some terrific harmonies between McVie and Nicks on the choruses.

#16 – Sugar Daddy (McVie, C.) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

I have always loved this light-hearted, playful offering from McVie off the Fleetwood Mac album. It’s such a fun, jaunty number, and you can hear Christine laughing at the end of the song. It shares a lot with the much more popular “Say You Love Me,” which may explain why the band has never performed the song live. It’s really all Christine… with her piano and organ really driving the song, along with a fantastic wandering bass line by her then husband John McVie. I love the way her organ part builds as the song progresses. The song is also a rarity for the time, as it featured a guest performer, Waddy Wachtel, on rhythm guitar. Christine’s vocal performance is spot on as well.

Lyrically, the song is about Christine longing for a sugar daddy, and older, wealthy gentleman to provide her with the comforts of life, but not for love. She’s got her man for that. It’s also got that fun car horn sound affect of a car horn just after the lines, “Well, he couple pick me up in a big fancy car,” and also during the song’s intro. I’ve included an early take of the song, without any guitar, that really highlights Christine’s piano and organ playing and shows off her early bluesy roots. Some may think “Sugar Daddy” is a throwaway song for Fleetwood Mac, but it always makes me happy and is one of my favorites. It has been since the album first came out.

Fleetwood Mac Tracks #’s 25 – 21

Fleetwood Mac circa 1975

A couple of Stevie’s big hits show up just before we crack the Top 20. It seems they should be higher on this list, it’s just that Fleetwood Mac has recorded so many damn good songs I couldn’t get them all into the Top 20! The songs in this batch really start to see all the stunning craftsmanship from the Fleetwood Mac and Rumours days. And so much nostalgia listening to all of these songs agin.

#25 – Blue Letter (Curtis, Michael; Curtis, Richard) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

Another great rocker from Lindsey Buckingham off the Fleetwood Mac album, and one of the rare times the band performed a song written by non-members. Michael & Richard Curtis were friends with Lindsey and Stevie during the Buckingham Nicks era, and they wrote this song for the recording duo for their sophomore album, which was never recorded. They offered the song to the pair as part of Fleetwood Mac, and the band decided late in the recording process to add it to the album. “Blue Letter” and “World Turning” were two of the last songs to be added, adding a slightly more high energy, rock ‘n roll edge to the album.

Powered largely by the Fleetwood Mac rhythm section, with a decidedly 70’s organ part and chunky guitars pushing the song along. “Blue Letter” features another nice blend of the three part harmonies that non one can do like Fleetwood Mac. It’s a quick number, but decidedly catchy and it has become a staple for many of their live concert tours.

#24 – The Chain (Buckingham, Fleetwood, McVie, C., McVie, J., Nicks) Rumours 1977

“The Chain” is the quintessential Fleetwood Mac song for so many reasons. It’s the only song with writing credits to the entire band. It highlights all the things that make Fleetwood Mac the band they are. The lyrics perfectly capture what the band was going through during the recording of Rumours. It’s symbolic of what the band has endured through the decades, with perhaps the sad exception of Lindsey’s forced departure a couple of years ago.

I recently found new appreciation for “The Chain” by really listening to it again after years of kind of just having it in the background of my mind. It’s really quite an amazing song, from the swamp rock twang of the guitar opener, to the outstanding vocal harmonies that no other band does quite the same way. The song was pieced together from bits and pieces of previous songs. Lindsey recycled a guitar lick from “Lola (My Love),” a track from the Buckingham Nicks album, and the iconic bass/drums break mid-way through the song was written by John McVie and Mick Fleetwood for Christine McVie-penned, never-released song called “Keep Me There,” that also provided the chord progression throughout. Stevie supplied the original lyrics that were reworked by she and Christine to the dark, yet powerful motifs that showed how out of the tumult and heartbreak came music that was so transcendent and universal that it acted as a chain that would keep them together.

“The Chain” really shows off all the band members doing what they do best. Lindsey’s guitar work, both in the dark, twangy intro, and during the blistering, incendiary solo is at its best. Christine provides a haunting, layered organ backdrop that builds to a simmering counterpoint during the final third of the song. Mick and John anchor the song with their impeccable rhythm section, with John’s iconic bass line providing perhaps the most memorable moment in the song, and Fleetwood’s powerful and intelligent drumming perfectly matching each of the song’s segments. And the vocals. Each vocalist brings their all, with their unique flavors. Lindsey and Stevie’s voices, so similar in some ways, entwine like vines, while Christine’s soaring harmonies add an ethereal quality that sends shivers up the spine.

Not my favorite Mac song, by any means, but I’m so glad it made the Top 25, as an important and emblematic moment in Fleetwood Mac history.

#23 – Honey Hi (McVie, C.) Tusk (1979)

This gem of a Christine McVie song seems just to have just been slipped onto Tusk without anyone noticing. In some ways it feels more like a snippet of a song, rather than an entire, finished song. It’s pretty short and almost feels like a jam session around a fire on the beach. It’s a got a super thrown together vibe, in the best way, although I’m sure it was very tightly produced.

From the get go, “Honey Hi” intrigues me, the way it fades in, like “Over My Head.: You don’t get too many fade ins, as I said before, it’s almost like you’re walking down the beach and you hear this music in the distance and you come up on a ragtag bunch of musicians just strumming along. It’s another song driven by Christine’s tuneful electric piano, something that always appeals to me, and I love the way Lindsey’s acoustic guitar weaves in and out, sometimes acting like a rhythm instrument, other times adding little flourishes to augment the simple melody. Mick’s percussion really adds so much texture and mood to the song. Bongos, rhythm sticks, a little tambourine, and occasional bell… so subtle and beautiful. Then there are the exquisite vocals. First, Christine’s amazing voice is perfect on this song, so pure and on point. And the when the three of them join their voice in superb harmony, you just can’t beat it. Christine, Stevie and Lindsey have such distinct voices, but the way they blend is nothing short of magical

The lyrics are pretty simple too. She’s traveling, probably on tour, and she’s reaching out to her partner who’s at home, telling him how much she misses and loves him. Simple, beautiful sentiment. I’ve included three videos for this song (overkill, I know). The first is the straightforward song. The second is likely an early demo of just Christine on the piano and singing, with some percussion. You get to really hear the great piano part. The final is a version of the recorded song with Christine’s piano and the harmonies taken out, so you can really listen to the gorgeous guitar licks from Lindsey, and you can really listen to how lovely Christine’s voice is.

#22 – Rhiannon (Nicks) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

If ever there was a song that really put Fleetwood Mac (and Stevie Nicks, for that matter) it was “Rhiannon,” Nicks’ song about a Welsh Witch, despite only climbing to #11 on the U.S. Billboard charts. For fans of the band who have seen them in concert, the band’s blistering performance of “Rhiannon” is one of the live show’s centerpieces, where as the song builds to a climax, the intensity of which is not found on the recording, it feels like the vocalist is exorcising an dark spirit. As a pre-teen, like many young people, I was enchanted by Nicks, and especially this song. I’m sure it was my favorite song on the album when I first heard it. Stevie’s mysterious and flamboyant presence was surely compelling.

“Rhiannon” was written before Nicks joined Fleetwood Mac, in the Buckingham Nicks days, but it was never recorded until the 1975 Fleetwood Mac album. Nicks was inspired to write the song after reading a novel in the early 70’s about a woman named Rhiannon who takes possession of another woman named Branwen. After she wrote the song, she did some research into the Welsh mythology and was so taken by it, she began to work on an extensive project about the character that was never completed. Another of Nicks’ Fleetwood Mac songs, which appears higher on this list is from that project.

This is a perfect example of how Fleetwood Mac, as a band, really enhances their members’ contributions. The production on the studio version of this song is impeccable, and the musicianship that each member brings to it is just perfect for the finished product. Once again, you just cant beat Fleetwood and McVie’s rhythm section. The drums pulse with a tribal rhythm like a heartbeat, with a rolling bass line to as a counterpoint. Christine’s bell-like electric piano drifts throughout the song like a bird in flight, catching your attention then wheeling away. Lindsey’s guitar makes for the songs most recognizable riff, and while he provides an explosive solo at the end of the live version, the restraint he exhibits on the recording serves the song beautifully. I truly swoon over the way the guitar and piano parts weave around each other creating a mystical aural tapestry. And finally, with no surprise at all, the three contribute gorgeous vocals to augment Stevie’s riveting and haunting performance. “Rhiannon” also features the first of Stevie’s now famous “fade-out” lines, where she introduces new lyrics as the song fades away.

I’ve included the studio version below, as well as the live version from The Dance that includes a gorgeous introduction featuring Christine on the grand piano, a version that is more similar to how Stevie wrote the song to begin with, and a live version from the Mirage tour that really shows off Stevie’s intense performance.

https://youtu.be/PZG6RY_6RmQ

#21 – Dreams (Nicks) Rumours (1977)

The fact that “Dreams” is Fleetwood Mac’s sole #1 single in the U.S. has always boggled my mind. While I enjoy the song, and when i really stop to listen to it, I think it’s one of their finest (just short of the Top 20, after all) recorded number. Chalk that up to Lindsey Buckingham’s masterful reworking of the original song contributed by Nicks, and the amazing production from the Rumours production. As reported in “Blender” magazine, Christine McVie described the song as having “just three chords and one note in the left hand” and “boring” when Nicks played a rough version on the piano. McVie changed her mind after Buckingham “fashioned three sections out of identical chords, making each section sound completely different. He created the impression that there’s a thread running through the whole thing. And there is a perfect example of how Fleetwood Mac is a better band when Lindsey Buckingham is a member.

Some of the things I love about the song are the way the verses are so sparse and open, really highlighting Stevie’s vocal performance, which is lovely. There’s the steady heartbeat of the drums and bass, while Christine’s electric piano provides the structure, and Lindsey’s fluid electric guitar provides the color. It’s a pretty standard formula for Fleetwood Mac, particularly the Nicks-penned number, but it clearly works. Then the chorus hits and bongo drums, an airy organ lick, and an acoustic guitar suddenly fill out the sound providing a lush background to the once again stellar three-part harmonies of our amazing vocalists, their unique, distinctive voices blending to create a seamless tapestry that is at once unified and disparate.

Lyrically, “Dreams” can be paired with Buckingham’s “Go Your Own Way,” (which will be making an appearance further up on this list) to show the slow unraveling of their relationship. “Now here you go again, you say you want your freedom. Well who am I to keep you down.” She accepting that things are over, but also providing a cautionary tale that it’s not going to make him happy, “But listen carefully to the sounds, of your loneliness, like a heartbeat drives you mad in the stillness of remembering what you had and what you lost.” It’s really a beautifully poetic summation of Stevie’s point of view around the collapse of their relationship.

Fleetwood Mac Tracks #’s 30 – 26

As we crack the Top 30, Lindsey Buckingham has a strong showing, with three songs in this next batch. The first song from 1997’s live album, The Dance also makes its first appearance in the Top 50.

#30 – Bleed to Love Her (Buckingham) The Dance (1997)

When Fleetwood Mac had their first major comeback in 1997 with a reunion concert and a live album, The Dance, in addition to all the classics hits, each songwriter included a new song. Lindsey Buckingham’s “Bleed to Love Her” is the stand-out of the new songs, and it anchors my Top 30 Mac tracks.

It’s a quick, straight-forward song for a Buckingham tune, but it’s heartfelt, melodic, with a catchy acoustic riff and gorgeous layered harmonies, anchored by a great bass & drum foundation. I don’t know what goes through Lindsey’s head when he writes songs, but twenty years past Rumours, it sure seems like he’s still writing about Stevie Nicks, and his emotional performance of this live track would suggest he’s still carrying a torch, or at least a match for her.

Apparently, I just found out this morning, that Fleetwood Mac included “Bleed to Love Her” for their 2003 album, Say You Will. It’s one of only two tracks that include Christine McVie on them, and that’s because those songs were originally recorded for a Lindsey Buckingham solo album, then co-opted for Fleetwood Mac’s 17th and final (so far) studio album. Say You Will was the first Mac album since 1970’s Kiln House that did not feature any songs written by Christine McVie. I’m including the video from The Dance because I like it better.

#29 – Monday Morning (Buckingham) Fleetwood Mac (1975)

The opening track from the album that heralded the massive leap in success for Fleetwood Mac, also introduced the world to the man who would arguably become the main creative driver for the band’s next 40 years. Lindsey Buckingham’s “Monday Morning” was written for the second Buckingham Nicks album, along with a couple other songs, but was moved to the Fleetwood Mac album when he and Nicks joined the band. It burst off the vinyl announcing a move from the blues-grounded British band, to a more pop-rock sound that would take the band to the highest of heights.

“Monday Morning” has a lot of trademarks: the way Lindsey uses his guitar as part of the rhythm section (a sound Christine duplicates with maracas in the live version), and Fleetwood employs his creative drumming style to give the song some terrific texture. The song structure is fun too, with a neat little bridge that guides the verses into the chorus. It truly was the dawn of a new day for the Mac, and the perfect way to open the multi-platinum Fleetwood Mac album

#28 – Walk a Thin Line (Buckingham) Tusk (1979

Buckingham’s highest-ranked song from Tusk was a late addition to the album, and while it still featured some of his more post-punk elements, it’s possible that he had divested some of the more out-there sounds and needed to return to his more melodic, pop sounds. “Walk a Thin Line” is a gorgeous, acoustic number that blends the best of Buckingham’s creative modes and creates an emotional ballad, that is… well, about his break-up with Stevie Nicks.

Interestingly enough, like “Monday Morning,” it kicks off with an intake of breath from Buckingham and a first line sung a cappella, then the drums and acoustic guitar lay down a rhythmic background the propels the song. Yet Buckingham’s music production wizardry takes some very simple elements and uses them to provide “Walk a Thin Line” with some sumptuous textures to back Buckingham’s haunting falsetto. The drums are multi-tracked to create a fascinating layered sound, and Buckingham and McVie’s backing vocals are used as a gorgeous counterpoint to the melody, the way another act might use strings or synthesizers.

While I appreciate and enjoy the creative antics Buckingham employed on Tusk (he recorded some of his vocals on this track in a push-up position as well), this pop number, laced with yearning and melody, stands out as my favorite.

#27 – I Don’t Want To Know (Nicks) Rumours (1977)

This country-twinged, upbeat pop number from Nicks was written back in the Buckingham Nicks days, and was a last minute addition to Rumours. “Silver Springs” had originally been slated to be Nicks’ third contribution to the album, but it’s running time put total album’s length over the limit. Without telling Nicks, the band recorded a version of “I Don’t Want To Know” with Lindsey singing both parts and decided to use the song as a replacement for “Springs.” When Mick Fleetwood broke the news to Stevie, she was originally angry that the band went behind her back to do this and wouldn’t have anything to do with the recording, but relented, not wanting to only have two songs featured on Rumours.

While “Silver Springs is clearly the better of the two songs, I’m glad they ended up recording “I Don’t Want To Know” as it’s one of Nick’s better songs with Fleetwood Mac. It’s “rockin’ and a reelin'” rhythm matches the lyrics and tone of the song, and the entire song is sung as a duet with beautiful Everly Brothers-style harmonies between Buckingham and Nicks. I also love the addition of Nicks’ hand-claps that are reminiscent of the 60’s pop groups like the Archies. Although it was written long before the pair was even thinking of breaking up, it fits the rest of the Rumours album lyrically as a conciliatory break-up song, much like Dreams.

#26 – Love in Store (McVie, C./Recor, Jim) Mirage (1982)

“Love in Store” kicks-off the 1982 Mirage album with all the best elements of a Fleetwood Mac track. The gorgeous, crystal production makes it possible to hear each and every instrument and vocal track while blending them all together in astounding pop perfection. The song is an understated pop gem, but it’s got an interesting, compact structure with only one round of verses to open the song, then chorus, break chorus, outro. It was released as the third single from Mirage , climbing to #22, after “Hold Me” (#4), “and Gypsy” (#12).

The song is driven by a demanding snare drum and propulsive bass line with electric piano and organ providing the through line and Lindsey’s guitar flourishes adding color. But it’s the signature three-part harmonies and textured background oohs and aahs that really provide Christine’s gorgeous vocals the rich palette to soar. Stevie’s harmonies get nicely highlighted, especially in the live version. And as is often the case in Christine’s songs, Lindsey provides the outro vocals. The song was co-written by Christine, and Jim Recor, who was married to Stevie Nicks’ friend Sara, who in the late 80’s had affair with Mick Fleetwood! It’s amazing how that band’s romantic dramas even spilled over onto their friends. “Love in Store” is the 4th of 5 tracks from Mirage to hit the Top 50, and 1st of 2 of McVie’s contributions to the album.

Fleetwood Mac Tracks #’s 35 – 31

#35 – Book of Love (Buckingham; Dashut, Richard) Mirage (1982)

“Book of Love” is a pretty straightforward song about having to deal with a broken heart while your former love is still around. (Again, does Lindsey write any Fleetwood Mac songs that aren’t about Stevie Nicks?) What I love most about this song, however, is the heartfelt, emotional way Buckingham sings it, especially the chorus. You can hear the pain in his voice as he channels that upper register but harnesses it for heartbreak rather than the shrieks and howls that he often uses in his live tracks from this era.

Buckingham’s work on Mirage was interesting as well, for while he certainly moved back to a more pop sensibility after his forays into punk experimentalism on Tusk, that influence is still there. While the soundscape of his songs is more layered than his tracks on Tusk, there is still a sparseness that opens up the song. The use of his colleagues on backing vocals has shifted to provide that layering, reminiscent of early Mac, but still with an edge that feels more of the time. As always, Buckingham’s guitar work is stellar; crisp and intricate and this song features a fantastic bass line from John McVie. There is clearly a new wave/punk spirit behind the pop songwriter. This song, along with a couple other Buckingham cuts on Mirage, were co-written with the album’s co-producer, Richard Dashut, who had been involved since the Buckingham Nicks days.

#34 – Not That Funny (Buckingham) Tusk 1979

When Tusk was released, the Lindsey Buckingham track that most captured me was “Not That Funny,” a rather whacky, offbeat number with a really unusual sound. I couldn’t get enough of this song, found it strangely compelling, and I think, like Lindsey, who wrote this song in response to the late ’70’s punk movement, helped usher me from the smooth grooves of the 70’s into the new style of music that defined the 80’s.

“Not That Funny” was almost completely driven by the grungy, distorted chunkiness of what I coined, “the Tusk guitar,” augmented by the annoyingly catchy, warped twanging of another guitar that faded in and out. The whole sound of this song was unusual, with Lindsey singing the entire vocal track in a plank position, with a microphone taped to the tile floor of a recreation of his home bathroom.

This, along with “Tusk” are arguably the weirdest songs ever recorded by Fleetwood Mac, and it’s no surprise that the live version retained Lindsey’s vocal eccentricities, but lost some of the wildly odd instrumentation. However, Christine stepped in with a funky piano accompaniment to fill in for the twangy, high-pitched acoustic guitar work, and the live version ends up becoming an extended jam session while Lindsey vocalizes his pain and eccentricity.

Lyrically, who quite know what this song’s all about, but it’s definitely coming from a dark place, despite being dressed up with all the offbeat sounds. “All your hope is gone… I said it’s not too funny, is it?” I still prefer the quirky studio version, and I do love playing this on the piano. In some ways I think this song informed some of my musician sensibility during my brief tenure in a punk band called “Psyclone” in the early 80’s.

#33 – Never Forget (McVie, C.) Tusk (1979)

Many fans of the Tusk album praise it by saying how the experimental quirkiness of Buckingham’s song is perfectly offset by the beauty and sweetness of McVie and Nicks’ contributions. Four of the ten tracks from Tusk that appear in my Top 50 are from McVie, and I would certainly rank them pretty high on the “beauty and sweetness” scale, none, perhaps, as highly as “Never Forget.” The closing track on Tusk, this sweet, melodic song is a simple song about love and remembrance that wraps up the adventure so aptly and so beautifully.

The gentle fade in with Christine’s electric piano, Lindsey’s acoustic guitar, and John McVie’s rambling bass interweaving so beautifully, with Mick’s driving rim shots moving the song forward. When Christine’s voice slides in you just feel so warm and comforted, and Buckingham and Nicks’ backing vocals glide along like a 70’s mellow rock classic. Little touches like Lindsey’s gentle electric guitar licks, and Christine’s organ augment the song as it carries the listener along on a gentle, warm wave of fond memories. The fade out with the three vocalists telling us that “It’ll be all right” just makes you feel like it really will.

#32 – Seven Wonders (Stewart, Sandy; Nicks) Tango in the Night (1987)

Other than one standout track on Tusk, and this cut from Tango in the Night you will notice that I lose interest in Stevie’s musical contributions after Rumours. I don’t know if she just saved her best songs for her solo career at that point, or I just found her becoming a bit of parody of herself, but her mystical, nonsensical meanderings didn’t catch me the way her early work did. But another interesting thing happened in the mid-80’s and the release of her second solo album, The Wild Heart, she started working with Sandy Stewart. Sandy sang and played keyboards on Nick’s The Wild Heart album, and co-wrote three of the songs, including the Top 20 single, “If Anyone Falls.” Stewart released a solo album, Cat Dancers, which remains one of my favorite little known albums of the 80’s, and a follow-up album as a band called Blue Yonder. While her solo career never took off, she began writing hit songs for such performers as Nicks, Tina Turner, Belinda Carlisle and others.

Stewart sent a demo of “Seven Wonders” to Fleetwood Mac during the recording of Tango, but didn’t include the lyric sheet. Nicks misheard one line of the lyrics as, “all the way down to Emmaline,” her sole contribution that got her a songwriting credit alongside Stewart. Nicks said of the moment, “I had become so attached to the name Emmaline that we kept it in and she gave me a small percentage.” It makes you wonder what the original line was.

For me it’s a great, upbeat, pop track for Nicks, and finds her in fine vocal form. The layered harmonies in the chorus are reminiscent of 70’s Mac. Fleetwood adds some fine rhythmic layering with added percussion, and it doesn’t sound overproduced despite all the synth work. And even though it’s just a performance piece, I enjoy the whimsy of the video, and the playful interplay between the members which you don’t often see. And Christine looks fantastic.

#31 – Why (McVie, C.) Mystery to Me (1973)

Mystery to Me was a great album for Christine McVie songs. All four of the albums tracks to hit the Top 50 come from McVie, and she really stretches her writing and experiments with some different styles here. “Why” is certainly a good example of Christine pushing on the boundaries of her traditional musical style. While lyrically, the songs fits squarely into McVie’s wheelhouse, lamenting over the end of a relationship, but knowing it’s time to move on, musically it’s pretty unique for her.

The song begins with a lengthy intro featuring guitarist Bob Weston’s trademark slide guitar, before sliding into the lovely acoustic guitar and piano that seem like more familiar McVie territory, melodic as ever. Honestly, the music and lyrics of the opening stanzas meld so perfectly… it sounds like the gentle dawning of a new day that’s filled with melancholy, yet somehow helpful as well. Weston’s guitar and McVie’s organ providing beautiful bridges between the verses, along with some ARP string synthesizers bringing additional texture. As always, Mick Fleetwood’s drums and John McVie’s bass add a subtle, yet complex foundation. Then McVie and Welch sing the beautiful refrain together to take us to a slow outro that brings us right back to where we started. It’s a truly lovely song that is a great example of how the music and lyrics match perfectly.

This is one of the songs from the pre-Buckingham/Nicks days that the band performed live for a while, and the closing refrain, that blended McVie, Nicks and Buckinghams’ voices elevated the song to new heights. While the live version lacks the complexity of the studio track, it’s beautiful in its own right. McVie’s singing just makes me tear up, and Buckingham’s guitar-work is stellar; I love the guitar/organ interplay after the second verse. John McVie gets his moment to shine, and it’s lovely to hear Nicks harmonize back when she had an upper register. I’ve included both the studio and live version below.

https://youtu.be/QxjDHw5FtOA